A clip of Jack Dorsey has been stuck in my head.
"We are being programmed based on what we say we're interested in and we are told through these discovery mechanisms what is interesting."
Preview stills are frames of the recording (Oslo Freedom Forum / Human Rights Foundation), served from this site, so no YouTube request occurs before interaction. After interaction, the player uses YouTube Privacy-Enhanced Mode. Both passages are quoted or described in the text, so the argument does not depend on the video. The full 20 minute conversation is here.
He said it on stage at the Oslo Freedom Forum in 2024, arguing the technology debate should move from free speech to free will.
I read that as a claim about influence rather than control: systems you cannot inspect shaping what gets placed in front of you. You do not have to agree with every Jack Dorsey worldview to find it unsettling. I don't.
But the question underneath is useful. Who gets the final say?
For most of the internet era, that fight happened on a screen. Instagram chose the next post. Spotify picked another song. Google decided which answer deserved the top of the page. Call it convenience, persuasion, or simply very good software. Then close the app.
That option disappears when software moves into the physical world. Your car can observe how you drive. Your thermostat knows when you are home. Your cameras see rooms you would never invite a stranger into.
The question stops being what the technology knows. It becomes what authority you handed it.
The car is the preview
The Federal Trade Commission's case against General Motors and OnStar is useful because nobody had to seize the steering wheel.
The FTC alleged that GM collected, used, and sold precise geolocation and driving-behavior data from millions of vehicles without adequately notifying consumers or obtaining affirmative consent. According to the complaint, some of that information went to consumer-reporting agencies, which used it to compile reports that insurance companies then used to set rates and deny insurance. In January 2026, the FTC finalized an order settling the allegations and banning GM for five years from disclosing that data to consumer-reporting agencies.
Follow the loop. You drive. The car observes. The observation becomes data. The data goes somewhere you cannot see. Another company makes a decision about you. That decision changes what driving costs.
The steering wheel never moved. The incentive did.
Calling that "the car taking away your free will" would be too dramatic, and it would miss the interesting part. Technology does not have to prevent a choice to reshape the environment around it.
Which is why privacy is increasingly the wrong-sized word here. Privacy matters. But autonomy gets closer: who observes, who decides, who can change the rules, and whether you can leave without losing what you already paid for.
Now bring it home
A connected home knows the shape of ordinary life. When you wake. When you leave. Which room is occupied. What temperature you prefer. Sometimes what you say.
None of that makes a smart home sinister. A motion sensor is not plotting against you. But the home is unusually intimate territory, so the architecture matters.
The researchers behind IoT Inspector built an open-source tool to study real smart-device network traffic, collecting metadata from more than 63,000 devices by 2022. In one case a Roku TV was seen contacting advertising services including DoubleClick and Scorecard Research.
They are careful about what that proves, and the care is the point. A network connection tells you a device contacted a service. It does not tell you why, or what happened next. Smart-home privacy does not benefit from spooky stories. It benefits from being able to look.
Sometimes we do know more. The FTC alleged Ring failed to restrict employee and contractor access to customers' private videos, and that weak security let attackers reach accounts and recordings. In a separate matter, the FTC and Justice Department alleged Amazon kept some Alexa voice and geolocation data after users tried to delete it, including children's.
Those are not arguments against cameras or voice assistants. They are reminders that putting a device in your home means entering a business relationship with whoever sits behind it. That relationship might be worth it. The point is knowing you entered it.
The cloud is not the villain
I am not anti-cloud. Remote access is useful. Voice assistants are useful. I am also not convinced that "local" automatically means "good." A Raspberry Pi in a closet with no backup, no documentation, and a household afraid to touch it is not sovereignty. It is just a different landlord.
The better question is whether a dependency is chosen, visible, replaceable, and recoverable. A cloud service can pass that test. A local system can fail it.
That is why I find Home Assistant interesting, and why we use it at RyzaLab. It gives us the option to run much of the home's logic and data inside the home, while still using cloud services where they earn the dependency. It does not magically make every device local. A product that depends on its manufacturer's cloud still depends on its manufacturer's cloud.
That test points at us too. If RyzaLab is one of your dependencies, you should be able to replace us without rebuilding the house. I would rather say so plainly than let a client assume it. The full version, the one worth asking of any installer including this one, runs to five questions.
The goal is not technological purity. It is understanding the trade before you make it.
Dorsey was talking about platforms and feeds. The argument gets sharper when software enters physical space, because a home becomes either a pile of invisible dependencies or a system whose dependencies were chosen deliberately.
We already ask who has our data. Inside the home, there is a better question: who does my home actually answer to?
The future I want is not a dumb home. It is a very smart one. I just want the answer to be simple: me.
RyzaLab's Smart Home Blueprint is a 60-minute assessment of your space, devices, routines, and priorities, ending in a written plan covering what to automate, what hardware to buy, what to skip, and who to call. It sits upstream of gadget selection. Book Your Blueprint.
Source notes
- Jack Dorsey, in conversation with Lyn Alden, "The Power of Open Source," Oslo Freedom Forum, June 2024. The quoted passage appears at approximately 13:57 in the Oslo Freedom Forum's own video of the conversation. HRF's recap paraphrases the same remarks, describing Dorsey arguing the free-speech debate should focus more on free will, especially as people are "being programmed by black box algorithms." Video · HRF recap
- Federal Trade Commission, General Motors / OnStar. Allegations of collecting, using, and selling precise geolocation and driving-behavior data without adequate notice and affirmative consent, including sales to consumer-reporting agencies whose reports were used by insurers. Order finalized January 2026. FTC action, Jan 2025 · FTC final order, Jan 2026
- Danny Yuxing Huang, "Three Years of Crowdsourcing Smart Home Network Traffic," USENIX, 2022. USENIX
- Federal Trade Commission, Ring, 2023. FTC
- Federal Trade Commission / Department of Justice, Amazon Alexa, 2023. FTC case page
- Home Assistant documentation. Is my data private? · Works without internet